Systematic reviews can help to justify a new randomized clinical trial (RCT), inform its design, and interpret its results in the context of prior evidence. Therefore, many stakeholders, including journals, funders, and research guidelines, have been promoting the citation of systematic reviews in RCT reports in the past two decades. However, it remains unclear whether such efforts have paid off. 

Recently, an international research team led by Drs. TANG Jinling, JIA Yuanxi from Shenzhen Institute of Advanced Technology (SIAT), Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS), collaborated with Dr. Karen A. Robinson from the School of Medicine, Johns Hopkins University have revealed that the citation of systematic reviews in RCT reports has improved. 

This study was published in JAMA Network Open on March 23, 2023. 

The research team conducted a cross-sectional study to investigate 4003 RCTs included in Cochrane reviews. Overall, 2265 RCTs (56.6%) cited systematic review; 1738 RCTs (43.4%) cited no systematic review. The percentage of RCTs citing systematic review increased from 35.5% before 2008 to 71.8% after 2020, with an annual increase of 3.0%. 

"The overall percentage increases, but we cannot be too optimistic. On the one hand, almost 30% of RCTs published after 2020 still failed to cite systematic reviews; on the other hand, in some clinical fields such as ophthalmology, the percentage was as low as 26%." Dr. JIA said, "Some RCTs were at high risk of missing systematic review in their reports, such as those recruiting less than 100 participants, received nonindustry funding, and conducted in low- or middle-income countries. We need to pay more attention to these RCTs in the future."  

The current efforts may not be adequate. For example, although some journals have been requesting the citation of systematic reviews, the percentage of RCT reports citing systematic reviews in these journals did not differ from other journals without such a request.  

"These findings suggest that we must develop new or more aggressive methods to further improve the use of systematic reviews in RCT reports," said Dr. JIA. 

Media Contact:
ZHANG Xiaomin
Email:xm.zhang@siat.ac.cn